The “iconic” view from Downley Common could be changed forever, residents fear, as plans to extend a historic barn in the Green Belt and AONB are submitted.

Hughenden Hall, a late 18th century barn that was part of Downley Farm in Plomer Green Lane, was converted around 20 years ago to create four new homes – but residents at one of the houses have submitted plans for an extension.

The proposals include plans for a two-storey extension to the side of the building as well as a glass link featuring steps down to a new gym and yoga space and an extension to a car port.

While the plans have garnered support from a number of residents, some have objected to the planned work, fearing it will change the courtyard feel of the barns and ruin the view from nearby Downley Common – a popular space for dog walkers and runners, where village events are held.

A resident living nearby, who did not want to be named, told the Bucks Free Press villagers were “up in arms” over the plans.

She said: “It will change the view from Downley Common, which is one of the most iconic views in Downley. It will close the courtyard in – people like the look of a rustic village, why would you want to destroy it?”

Also objecting to the plans, Sander and Kirsty de Groot wrote a letter to Wycombe District Council saying the use of a glass link to connect the building will “detract from the historic buildings forming the development”.

They added: “We relocated to this heritage site under the impression that its character and style would be celebrated, cared for and retained. We fear that the proposed extension to Hughenden Hall would irrevocably change the character of the Grade II listed buildings and entire site, for the worse.”  

Another Downley resident, Stephen Davison added: “The barns are a lovely rural setting in the village and are a focal point from across the common. I feel the proposed additions too large and intrusive, with the addition of a glass gym to be totally out of keeping.

“I do hope common sense prevails and we can continue to enjoy the views as they were originally built.”

Jonathan Dale, speaking on behalf of Jane Duncan Architects, who are working with the applicants, said the planned extension “simply puts back a part of the barn that was removed some 20 years ago when the old farm buildings were converted into houses.”

He said: “As architects for the proposed works at Hughenden Hall, we were sad to learn that some of the adjacent residents have objected to our proposals and we met with some of them last week to discuss their concerns. 

“However, it is only fair to highlight that at the time of writing a number of letters of strong support from local residents have also been submitted to the planning department, all heartily endorsing our proposals.

“Throughout the design process we have consulted with Wycombe District Council and following a really positive pre-application meeting with both the Historic Buildings Officer and the Planning Officer, we amended our designs in accordance with their comments.”