News RSS Feed


Fury over phone mast by school

2:02pm Thursday 24th July 2008

comment Comments (8)   Have your say »

By Tom Pochciol »

RESIDENTS have united to oppose a plan to put a 40 ft high phone mast just yards from a primary school.

Phone company Orange plans to build the antenna at the junction of Foxes Piece and Little Marlow Road.

The site is around the corner from Foxes Piece Combined School, which has a nursery, and Brooke Furmston Place, which provides sheltered accommodation for elderly people.

Residents have raised their objections with Wycombe District Council, which can force the company to submit a planning application.

They fear radiation from the "eyesore" mast could pose health risks.

However, an independent report commissioned by the Government in 2000 found radiation from phone masts, or base stations, was not dangerous.

The Stewart Report said "the balance of evidence indicates that there is no general risk" to health.

Radiation from the masts was a small fraction of the acceptable limit, it said.

Yet it warned further research may uncover health risks - and sites should therefore be chosen carefuly.

Charles Horth, 67, a consultant in the pharmaceutical industry for more than 40 years, said: "The tobacco companies said, smoking isn't bad for you, people have been smoking for years'."

Mr Horth, who lives in Maple Rise, less than 40 metres from the proposed site, said: "It was only later that people started saying that smoking is a cause of cancer.

"Stewart is saying that we need to take a precautionary approach."

He said: "Orange wants to plonk it in a busy location near to a petrol station and a school and expect the community to say, thank you very much Orange, we're going to get good use out of this'."

Paul Lynch, of Foxes Piece, said parents "need to have peace of mind that their children are safe".

Carolyn Margetson, of Lower Road, Cookham, said: "I have grave concerns regarding the proposal as this is a residental area."

As the proposed mast is less than 45ft (15m) tall Orange does not have to apply to the district council for planning permission.

The authority can, however, force the developer to submit a planning application, which it can then accept or refuse.

Martin Grey, spokesman for Orange, said 30 "independent expert reviews" had found "no adverse health effects".

"Ofcom has undertaken more than 500 independent audits of base stations across the length and breadth of the UK.

"The measurements from these independent audits show emissions levels from base stations are typically small fractions of the international guidelines.

"The location balances the requirement to maintain local network coverage with respect for amenity, and our application follows extensive consultation with Wycombe District Council."

Your Say YourBucks

Welwyn Dowd, Wycombe says...
2:09pm Thu 24 Jul 08

Charles Horth, 67, a consultant in the pharmaceutical industry for more than 40 years

Was he one of the consultants that approved Thalidomide as safe for use?

stewj, Loudwater says...
4:14pm Thu 24 Jul 08

so decent reception for once about time


R of Wycombe, High Wycombe says...
4:15pm Thu 24 Jul 08

Rather interesting that this has been published today

http://news.bbc.co.u
k/1/hi/health/752310
9.stm

Kadoogan, Wycombe says...
4:40pm Thu 24 Jul 08

Even assuming you can get cancer from a mobile phone signal (so far totally unproven), it's a good thing that the mast will be close. I suspect most of the kids have mobile phones. If they are on Orange their phones will be working at a much reduced power due to the proximity of the mast, so their heads will be absorbing less 'mobile death rays'. I suspect the people whining about this have never bothered to actually look at the science behind how the signals actually work.

Blueberry, S Bucks says...
9:59am Fri 25 Jul 08

I suspect the "fury" is only from some residents - and I wonder how many of them have mobiles, for which they want a signal?

This is just a mast they know about and that can't be stopped as it doesn't require planning. There are ltos of other hidden ones.

And if they're so worried about such things, what about their neighbours wi-fi? No permission required for that, and no escape either.

Blueberry, S Bucks says...
10:00am Fri 25 Jul 08

Apologies for typos above!

johnson1978, stevenage says...
2:08am Tue 29 Jul 08

Blueberry, you are absolutely right, we need to get some kind of protection against our neigbours polluting our own homes with all types of wireless equipment.

The truth though, is that it is indeed here where the first litigation will take place. The law in this country appears to be such that it is the home and business owners who allow (masts, for example) to be on their property, who will be liable. Not the big companies. It does seem sad but I'm sure you will agree this will lead to the escape you wish for.

Also you are spot on about all the masts that people can't see. It is probably this fact (and also that most public wi-fi networks and masts are tested for a few weeks before the publicised 'going live' date) that stops the majority of the public realising what is making them ill.

I sympathise with all your negativity on this, we have all been there, but there is hope that the ignorant will soon be able to understand.

I hope this helps

Kadoogan, Wycombe says...
4:24pm Wed 30 Jul 08

johnson1978

Before branding those of us that don't froth at the mouth about this as ignorant, how about proving there is any danger from mobile phone and other wireless signals?

There is an infamous case where a mast was built and people in the surrounding area over the next 6 months complained it was making them ill. It then transpired that the mast had never been switched on. Quit reading the hysterical tabloid nonsense that is only there to sell newspapers and actually read up on the technology.

Your sayYourBucks

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE Bucks Free Press account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.




Forgotten your password?

Hot Jobs

Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »