Campaigners slam 'derisory' HS2 compensation package

Campaigners slam 'derisory' HS2 compensation package Campaigners slam 'derisory' HS2 compensation package

'DERISORY' and 'cynical' is how HS2 campaigners have described a compensation package revealed by the Department for Transport today.

People living 60 metres either side of the where the line is proposed to go will receive the full value of their home and may also get a further ten per cent on top of that.

In rural areas - such as the Chiltern hills, which the route is planned to cut through - the government will ensure homeowners can sell their property at the amount it would have been worth if HS2 was not built.

But opponents of the plans said the compensation scheme - now subject to a consultation which closes on January 31 - did not go far enough.

And they also questioned where funding for the scheme - described by the DfT as going beyond statutory requirements - would come from.

Hilary Wharf, Director of the HS2 Action Alliance, said: "This is neither a generous nor the right package for those impacted by the plans for HS2. Under these proposals many thousands of ordinary people will be left with houses they cannot sell or worth considerably less than they were before the plans for this eye watering expensive white elephant were announced. It offers no prospect of relief for the vast majority of those whose lives are ruined by HS2.

"What’s on offer is derisory. It’s cynical and dishonest and gives the lie to repeated government promises that this would be the most generous compensation scheme ever. They themselves say it’s comparable to HS1’s arrangements – regarded as unacceptable 20 years ago."

Joe Rukin of Stop HS2 said: "While we are pleased that after two and a half years the government has finally recognised the damage HS2 is causing to communities along the route, we see this as a cynical, uncosted attempt to buy off the opposition to the project, and it will not work.

"Today, subject to the outcomes of the consultation, the Government has massively increased the cost of the HS2 project to astronomically unaffordable proportions. What the cost of compensation will be now is anyone's guess."

He added: "It is clear that the environmental damage which HS2 will reap has multiplied significantly today as well."

And Martin Tett, chairman of the 51m action group, said: "The announcement today changes nothing of 51m's view. The Department for Transport needs to go back to the drawing board on HS2."

All properties in the ‘safeguarded area’ 60 metres either side of the route will be bought at the full value by the government, while homeowners can sell for the full value in a 'voluntary purchase zone' 60 metres beyond that.

A long term hardship scheme to help those who need to move during the development of HS2 but who are unable to sell their home will also be set up.

Rail minister Simon Burns said: "No major infrastructure project on this scale can be built without some impact on local communities, but I am determined to do everything I can to minimise the effect of HS2 on those closest to the line.

"We have developed the right compensation package, providing absolutely the right support for those affected, while at the same time protecting the interests of taxpayers. We have thought long and hard about this and the measures I have announced are fair and strike the right balance for local communities and the British taxpayer."

Comments (5)

4:44pm Thu 25 Oct 12

sparky49 says...

Why worry, when the tunnel is extended you won't need to sell or move. Problem solved. Or do they want HS 2? House worth 470 thousand govt gives 517 thousand then buy for 500 thousand 17 grand in the bin. Result.
Why worry, when the tunnel is extended you won't need to sell or move. Problem solved. Or do they want HS 2? House worth 470 thousand govt gives 517 thousand then buy for 500 thousand 17 grand in the bin. Result. sparky49

4:56pm Thu 25 Oct 12

motco says...

Never heard of the punitive levels of stamp duty? 4% at that price. Legal fees, survey fees, removal costs...

Apart from which the width of the land over which compensation will be offered is tiny. A 250mph train will, even underground, shake the foundations for a long way. Then there's the construction chaos.
Never heard of the punitive levels of stamp duty? 4% at that price. Legal fees, survey fees, removal costs... Apart from which the width of the land over which compensation will be offered is tiny. A 250mph train will, even underground, shake the foundations for a long way. Then there's the construction chaos. motco

2:06pm Fri 26 Oct 12

Malc London says...

60 metres is nothing, and giving full market value is not enough.

If you are forced out of your home, as people living in around 550 houses will be, then they should be also compensated for inconvenience.

Imagine being told you have to move from a house you have lived in years and spent time and money on. You'd expect more than just the asking price.
60 metres is nothing, and giving full market value is not enough. If you are forced out of your home, as people living in around 550 houses will be, then they should be also compensated for inconvenience. Imagine being told you have to move from a house you have lived in years and spent time and money on. You'd expect more than just the asking price. Malc London

6:56pm Sun 4 Nov 12

Chiltonians says...

Sounds like you haven't read the consultation on compensation.

It is full market value of the property (impacted by HS2) plus an additional sum of 10% (up to a value of £47.5k.)

So if the market value of your house is £475k you basically get £522.500.
Sounds like you haven't read the consultation on compensation. It is full market value of the property (impacted by HS2) plus an additional sum of 10% (up to a value of £47.5k.) So if the market value of your house is £475k you basically get £522.500. Chiltonians

11:07am Sat 10 Nov 12

Chiltonians says...

And - it also pays your stamp duty (3%).
And - it also pays your stamp duty (3%). Chiltonians

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree