Chiltern CCG concerned about 'super hospital' plan

Bucks Free Press: Dr Gamell Dr Gamell

A KEY group of Bucks doctors has “significant concerns” over an MP’s radical plan for a regional Thames Valley hospital.

Dr Phillip Lee, Conservative MP for Bracknell, is set to hold a meeting in High Wycombe tomorrow evening to discuss his proposals for a ‘super hospital’ at Junction 8/9 of the M4.

The plan would involve the closure and sale of whole hospital sites such as Wexham Park, as well as part closures at others, including Wycombe Hospital.

It has been welcomed by some Bucks campaigners, however, who think the new hospital would be a better option for Wycombe patients who currently have to travel to Stoke Mandeville for key services such as A&E. 

But GPs who are set to take over the Bucks NHS budget have today listed several concerns about Dr Lee’s scheme.

Chiltern Clinical Commissioning Group [CCG] paid a private firm called Healthplanning to look into the proposals, and has today released its report.

Dr Annet Gamell, the CCG's chief clinical officer, wrote an open letter to Dr Lee which summarises the potential problems.

She said a ‘Royal Thames Valley Hospital’ would lead to a dramatically reduced level of acute services at Wycombe and Stoke Mandeville hospitals, whereas Berkshire would have two acute hospitals within its boundaries and two nearby.

To fund the new £750 million hospital from land sales at existing hospital sites is “highly optimistic”, the letter adds, as many have complex planning histories and selling them for development may not be straightforward.

Dr Gamell says the concept of larger ‘centres of excellence’ is acceptable to the public, but “it would be hard to justify the benefits of such a considerable shift in services”.

She says the CCG shares “much common ground” with Dr Lee about the clinical pressures driving the NHS, but sees developing the current network of hospitals within Bucks as a better option.

She adds: “Whilst Chiltern CCG has significant concerns about the impact of this hospital on our population, we recognise that your proposals are a serious contribution to what is a necessary debate about the future direction of health services in the area.

“We wish to continue to engage in this debate in a constructive and meaningful way, and welcome this opportunity to clarify our views.”

Healthplanning director Richard Mills, formerly of NHS Buckinghamshire, authored the CCG’s report.

Comments (8)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

4:03pm Wed 23 Jan 13

Darren Hayday says...

Dear Dr Gamell, Why can't we please keep Wycombe open and return the lost services back to us?
Dear Dr Gamell, Why can't we please keep Wycombe open and return the lost services back to us? Darren Hayday
  • Score: 0

4:15pm Wed 23 Jan 13

Cressex Offender says...

I'll second that. If that's not an option then I vote for this new hospital. Stoke Mandeville is too far from Wycombe to be any use.
I'll second that. If that's not an option then I vote for this new hospital. Stoke Mandeville is too far from Wycombe to be any use. Cressex Offender
  • Score: 0

5:09pm Wed 23 Jan 13

pennman says...

yes, restore the Wycombe facilities please.
yes, restore the Wycombe facilities please. pennman
  • Score: 0

5:10pm Wed 23 Jan 13

geriatrix says...

Make the re-opening of the closed parts of our Wycombe Hospital a number one issue at the next election. Anything else will cost lives. Nail down candidates to a firm unambiguous statement on this issue.
Make the re-opening of the closed parts of our Wycombe Hospital a number one issue at the next election. Anything else will cost lives. Nail down candidates to a firm unambiguous statement on this issue. geriatrix
  • Score: 0

5:16pm Wed 23 Jan 13

Emma179 says...

I can only second what everyone else says. Wycombe needs its own hospital.
I can only second what everyone else says. Wycombe needs its own hospital. Emma179
  • Score: 0

5:32pm Wed 23 Jan 13

shaky2 says...

Yes I too agree Wycombe should have it's own Hospital but I don't think this Goverment are listening to us
Yes I too agree Wycombe should have it's own Hospital but I don't think this Goverment are listening to us shaky2
  • Score: 0

6:07pm Wed 23 Jan 13

demoness the second says...

Wycombe is the largest town in Bucks ( not including Milton Keynes - technically it is a unitary authority and does not count).
It is near a major motorway. has schools and a university surrounding it.
It makes no sense not to have its own hospital - or at the very least an A and E and maternity and children's unit.
Wycombe is the largest town in Bucks ( not including Milton Keynes - technically it is a unitary authority and does not count). It is near a major motorway. has schools and a university surrounding it. It makes no sense not to have its own hospital - or at the very least an A and E and maternity and children's unit. demoness the second
  • Score: 0

11:03am Thu 24 Jan 13

geoffW says...

Dr Gamell said that a ‘Royal Thames Valley Hospital’ would lead to a dramatically reduced level of acute services at Wycombe and Stoke Mandeville hospitals, whereas Berkshire would have two acute hospitals within its boundaries and two nearby.

Guess where Dr Lee's constituency is!
Dr Gamell said that a ‘Royal Thames Valley Hospital’ would lead to a dramatically reduced level of acute services at Wycombe and Stoke Mandeville hospitals, whereas Berkshire would have two acute hospitals within its boundaries and two nearby. Guess where Dr Lee's constituency is! geoffW
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree