Survey shows national opinion split on HS2

Survey shows opinion split on HS2 Survey shows opinion split on HS2

A POLL suggests more people are opposed to HS2 than support it - but opinion on the controversial project is split.

A survey carried out by leading opinion pollsters YouGov shows 43 per cent of people oppose the scheme and 41 per cent are in favour of it.

But it also suggested people living in the north are more likely to be opposed to it - with nearly half of all people living in Scotland saying they did not support the scheme.

A total of 49 per cent of Scots said they opposed the new high speed line while 38 per cent said they were in favour.

London was the only geographical area where more respondents said they supported HS2, with 42 per cent in favour and 39 per cent opposed.

Government ministers have said the line will bring renewed economic growth to the north and this is a key reason why it should be built.

The Sunday Times-commissioned poll also revealed more than half the people who intended to vote Conservative at the next election were in favour and Labour supporters were most likely to oppose it.

The figures also showed men were more supportive of the project than women. More than 2,000 people were questioned for the survey.

Chiltern District Councillor Seb Berry, who stood for election by protesting against HS2, said he was encouraged by the results of the poll.

He said: "For nearly three years, we've been told by ministers that the only people opposed to HS2 are those they consider to be route NIMBYs. Here are the polling numbers from Scotland, the north of England and elsewhere to prove the exact opposite. 

"Given the pro HS2 editorial line of most papers, plus blanket broadcast coverage of ministers and pro-HS2 Labour MPs last week, this is a very encouraging result for the campaign."

Comments (2)

12:40pm Mon 4 Feb 13

miccles says...

Given the publicity this has got, and the amount of people who allegedly are opposed to this, 43% is not alot really.
Given the publicity this has got, and the amount of people who allegedly are opposed to this, 43% is not alot really. miccles

5:54pm Wed 6 Feb 13

kerlmann says...

This is a hugely complex issue and one laden with political stigma and ego-centric posturing.

You can't realistically ask people whether they're in favour of it unless they know all the pros and cons in reasonable detail. Is there anyone out there that does...? Anyone at all??

In principle, it seems a good idea to get more cars off the road, but the reality of the project (cost, payback, compromise, environmental impact, business boost) is so subjective currently that these research figures don't reveal much at all.
This is a hugely complex issue and one laden with political stigma and ego-centric posturing. You can't realistically ask people whether they're in favour of it unless they know all the pros and cons in reasonable detail. Is there anyone out there that does...? Anyone at all?? In principle, it seems a good idea to get more cars off the road, but the reality of the project (cost, payback, compromise, environmental impact, business boost) is so subjective currently that these research figures don't reveal much at all. kerlmann

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree