Send your news, photos and videos by texting bucksfreepress to 80360 or email
7:30am Thursday 5th August 2010 in
RARE wildlife will be under threat if plans for a high speed rail route through the Chiltern district go ahead, a conservationist has warned.
Heather Lewis of the Berkshire, Buckinghamshire and Oxfordshire Wildlife Trust said the planned railway line would be “like the Berlin Wall” because of the impact it would have on the environment.
The preferred route of the High Speed 2 rail project would cut through the Chilterns Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty in a series of tunnels and cuttings.
But this would go through three Sites of Special Scientific Interest, nine areas of Ancient Woodland and two of the Wildlife Trust's nature reserves. The preferred alternative line, further south towards the Hughenden Valley, would go through 13 Ancient Woodlands.
Miss Lewis, the Buckinghamshire Conservation Officer for the Trust, said this would break up animals' feeding grounds and destroy habitats, leading to declining populations – which she said were already “dropping off at quite a frightening rate”.
She said animals follow tree lines and natural landmarks to find their way around – but they would no longer be able to do this if the railway line is built.
Among the threatened species is a rare Coralroot plant, which is found in just two locations in the UK – one of which is in Weedon Hill Woods near Amersham.
Miss Lewis told the Bucks Free Press: “By fragmenting the landscape like this, you may as well have a 75 metre-wide wall. It will be like the Berlin Wall of wildlife as they won't be able to get across to the other side.
“The Government's argument will be they will recreate these habitats. What they don't understand is the adjacent fields will be agricultural and will have had pesticides used on them and won't necessarily be suitable.
“If the Government think they can create new landscapes elsewhere, they are wrong. They will never have these habitats back to this quality.”
She added: “I haven't seen any justification for the route they have chosen. They haven't convinced us from an environmental aspect. They haven't done an assessment to say, environmentally, that's the best route.”
Sites of Special Scientific Interest are protected by law, and an area of Ancient Woodland can only be designated if it is at least 400 years old.
Miss Lewis said: “They have been managed for years specifically to bring them up to a certain quality. You can't recreate them just like that, and it's impossible to recreate an area of ancient woodland.”
Embankments either side of the line will need to be cleared of vegetation, which Miss Lewis said would create a 75-metre wide “dead zone” where the line is built. The railway lines would take up 25 metres of room, and there needs to be at least 25 metres of room on either side, she said.
She was speaking after a delegation visited Kent to look at the impact the previous High Speed 1 project has had on the county.
For a full report on the visit, see Friday's Bucks Free Press.
Comments(23)
ferrellcat
says...
8:41am Thu 5 Aug 10
demoness
says...
8:51am Thu 5 Aug 10
ferrellcat wrote:FC - you are missing the point.
outstanding natural beauty it may be but most of us never see it because its all fenced in and exclusive to those that own it.There are several wooded areas around here that you can no longer walk through.Maybe a train is what is needed to open up the countryside to us all.And on size its no bigger than a motorway and they seem to have an abundance of wild life.Its great to protect something but in this case it is just for the few
tom.marlow
says...
8:57am Thu 5 Aug 10
ferrellcat
says...
9:17am Thu 5 Aug 10
pennman
says...
9:36am Thu 5 Aug 10
tom.marlow
says...
9:52am Thu 5 Aug 10
miccles
says...
10:01am Thu 5 Aug 10
Morag
says...
10:09am Thu 5 Aug 10
tom.marlow wrote:Yet the Government is seriously considering cancelling the £1bn electrification of the Great Western Line from Paddington to Swansea, which was announced by the previous Labour Government. Electrification is essential as a first building block towards high-speed rail provision.
Its not about the the initial phase to Birmingham, its about building a network intot he northwest and scotland.
MCarey
says...
10:46am Thu 5 Aug 10
tom.marlow
says...
10:49am Thu 5 Aug 10
miccles wrote:Actually, I think Heather Lewis is just doing her job, which is to present the interests of the BBOWT and their nature reserves.
My personal view is i think "Heather Lewis", "should get a life", and start thinking of something that really matters, if all she can think about is a "rare coral root plant", and what are the animals going to do, then i feel sorry for her. If this is going to happen, it will happen, where? when? who knows, its not going to be stopped just because somebody says it's going to upset the wildlife, who cares? You can bet your bottom dollar, all these enviromental whingers, if this goes ahead, and they are still alive, sometime in their life they will use it, these sort of people are just hypocrites i'm afraid, and they know it. and i know this is going to cause a storm by some.
tom.marlow
says...
10:52am Thu 5 Aug 10
Morag wrote:The tories don't exactly have much of a track record with railways :-)
tom.marlow wrote: Its not about the the initial phase to Birmingham, its about building a network intot he northwest and scotland.Yet the Government is seriously considering cancelling the £1bn electrification of the Great Western Line from Paddington to Swansea, which was announced by the previous Labour Government. Electrification is essential as a first building block towards high-speed rail provision. ~ A recent Greengauge21- sponsored KPMG assessment of the economic impacts of HS2 indicates that the scheme will have a net negative impact on the economies of Wales and south-west of England. ~ The last thing Cardiff and Bristol need is to see cities such as Leeds and Manchester getting even closer in journey times to London.
tom.marlow
says...
10:54am Thu 5 Aug 10
MCarey wrote:yet we can afford to renew a fleet of submarines armed with nuclear missiles?
if you want to go to scotland fly there, we are too small an island for such a huge unnecessary rail line, its a waste of money worry and ripping up of the supposed protected countryside oh and by the way the country cant even afford to build it
Arkwright
says...
12:40pm Thu 5 Aug 10
pennman wrote:I very much doubt that anybody in Birmingham would be remotely interested in coming to High Wycombe either - hardly a centre of a retail nor decent nightlife. What a dump!
No-one wants to go to Birmingham anyway! We've already destroyed the landscape with the M40, so why not use it? It is a lot cheaper than using over-priced and unreliable trains.
Malc London
says...
12:49pm Thu 5 Aug 10
J B Blackett
says...
12:59pm Thu 5 Aug 10
Arkwright wrote:Thanks for those unnecessary gratuitous nasty and irrelevant remarks about Wycombe.
pennman wrote:I very much doubt that anybody in Birmingham would be remotely interested in coming to High Wycombe either - hardly a centre of a retail nor decent nightlife. What a dump!
No-one wants to go to Birmingham anyway! We've already destroyed the landscape with the M40, so why not use it? It is a lot cheaper than using over-priced and unreliable trains.
daemonite
says...
1:20pm Thu 5 Aug 10
J B Blackett
says...
2:01pm Thu 5 Aug 10
Slimster
says...
3:03pm Thu 5 Aug 10
demoness wrote:This kind of drama-queen effect doesn't wash with me. The house you live in was built on what was once a field or a forest. I agree that we need to minimise the impact on the environment, but we can't hold back development simply because it changes things. On one hand people don't want LHR to have another runway, OK, well what other communication links in place? A railway is a good alternative. Whereever it goes it will be through someone's backyard/rabbit burrow.
THIS is exactly what I have been banging on about since the wretched plans came to light.
Once these animals and plans have gone, that is it.... gone forever.
THE EARTH DOES NOT BELONG TO HUMANS!!! We share it with a lot of other living creatures to and we have NO RIGHT to destroy their habitats .
Michael, HP7
says...
3:54pm Thu 5 Aug 10
hondo
says...
4:10pm Thu 5 Aug 10
efbog
says...
5:11pm Thu 5 Aug 10
demoness
says...
9:49pm Thu 5 Aug 10
hondo wrote:I really hope you are right Hondo :(
Dear, dear, why are you all getting your knickers in a knot about something which isn't going to happen?
~
This is all about Tony and Gordon's graduates doing "planning", something for which they were obviously not "qualified", but for which they were subsidised by the tax-payer as part of the Labour Party's "eduction,education, education" policy to keep them from being registered as unemployed.
If there were a requirement, don't you think some-one might have done it before?
~
Communication is now done on the internet; no individual really needs to reduce the time between London and Birmingham on a train. (Please contradict and justify - or move house/job).
~
Optionally; get a life.
Enter your postcode, town or place name
Find a job in Buckinghamshire.
Search Now »
Make a date in Buckinghamshire now!
Search Now »
Search for properties across the UK.
Search Now »
Find used vehicles for sale in Buckinghamshire
Search Now »
demoness says...
7:35am Thu 5 Aug 10
Once these animals and plans have gone, that is it.... gone forever.
THE EARTH DOES NOT BELONG TO HUMANS!!! We share it with a lot of other living creatures to and we have NO RIGHT to destroy their habitats .