Chesham and Amersham MP Cheryl Gillan: Why HS2 should be scrapped

Cheryl Gillan, MP: Why HS2 should be scrapped

Cheryl Gillan, MP: Why HS2 should be scrapped

First published in News

THIS week Cheryl Gillan, MP for Chesham and Amersham and former cabinet minister, writes for the Bucks Free Press on why the controversial HS2 project should be scrapped.

It is a relief to be able to speak freely about the proposed High Speed 2 rail project, now that I am no longer bound by being a Cabinet Minister.

There has never been a vote in parliament on HS2 on whether it should go ahead and I do not believe that it should proceed. At over £32 billion it is too expensive and with an ever-falling benefit-cost ratio (currently standing at 1.2), the economic benefits have certainly not been proved yet. It is not good value for money for the taxpayer. The environmental damage to the protected landscape of the Chilterns would be immense, particularly in the South Heath and Great Missenden areas where cuttings would leave a scar across the AONB.

HS2 is by far the biggest challenge which facing Chesham and Amersham and constituencies along the proposed route. Never in my 20 years as constituency MP has there been an issue which created so much concern and distress.

The argument about HS2 is not and never has been about the culture of Not In My Back Yard. The Chilterns AONB is a national asset, a treasure of the kind that cannot be replaced.

I gave fellow Cabinet members a hard time over HS2 and I do not regret that. The fight on behalf of constituents in Chesham and Amersham has continued in Westminster and Whitehall day in and day out.

Whilst being a thorn in the side of Cabinet colleagues, I have expressed gratitude when mitigation measures were proposed. This is not the politics of defeatism. I have not accepted a fait accompli. Yes, it would be dreadful for this project to go ahead. But for the project to go ahead without mitigation measures would be truly dreadful and a betrayal of the people living along the proposed route. This is why I am working closely with local groups and engineers on alternative proposals for a fully-bored tunnel through the entire constituency and still looking at alternative routes.

The day I put my Ministerial red box to one side, I tackled the new Transport Secretary - to ask him to axe HS2. With my departure from Government I intend to continue my staunch opposition, now in public instead of behind closed doors.

There is a different range of weapons and tactics at the disposal of an MP sitting on the back benches. There are Parliamentary Questions and interventions. There is the work carried out by Select Committees in testing and validating the decisions of the government of the day. All these can and will play a part in challenging this project.

From Day 1 of the Coalition Government it was obvious that the Labour Government had created so much debt that it would burden this country for generations. Economic growth is essential. But we have to ensure that every penny of public money is spent wisely and well. We, literally, cannot afford to pour good money after bad, in the hope of an economic miracle.

Comments (8)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

9:32am Thu 13 Sep 12

BabyBoosh says...

So why couldn't she speak freely? If cabinet ministers cannot support issues within their own constituencies then perhaps this should be addressed?

Sucking up to us now is quite frankly too late!
So why couldn't she speak freely? If cabinet ministers cannot support issues within their own constituencies then perhaps this should be addressed? Sucking up to us now is quite frankly too late! BabyBoosh
  • Score: 0

10:45am Thu 13 Sep 12

Darren Hayday says...

BabyBoosh wrote:
So why couldn't she speak freely? If cabinet ministers cannot support issues within their own constituencies then perhaps this should be addressed?

Sucking up to us now is quite frankly too late!
Here here! She should have resigned a long time ago if this was playing on her conscience. Not wait till she lost her job and then jump on the band wagon.
But she will still get voted back in again – because that’s the way of the political system – it’s a fix!
[quote][p][bold]BabyBoosh[/bold] wrote: So why couldn't she speak freely? If cabinet ministers cannot support issues within their own constituencies then perhaps this should be addressed? Sucking up to us now is quite frankly too late![/p][/quote]Here here! She should have resigned a long time ago if this was playing on her conscience. Not wait till she lost her job and then jump on the band wagon. But she will still get voted back in again – because that’s the way of the political system – it’s a fix! Darren Hayday
  • Score: 0

12:20pm Thu 13 Sep 12

banknote says...

If you believe that HS2 is wrong but that is government policy, then you resign your cabinet position - not wait until you're sacked.

This type of behavior is what gives politics a really bad name. As a lifelong Conservative, I would not vote for her.
If you believe that HS2 is wrong but that is government policy, then you resign your cabinet position - not wait until you're sacked. This type of behavior is what gives politics a really bad name. As a lifelong Conservative, I would not vote for her. banknote
  • Score: 0

1:45pm Thu 13 Sep 12

J B Blackett says...

banknote wrote:
If you believe that HS2 is wrong but that is government policy, then you resign your cabinet position - not wait until you're sacked.

This type of behavior is what gives politics a really bad name. As a lifelong Conservative, I would not vote for her.
The argument used by these traitorous politicians is that they cannot speak what they think because they are governed by what they deviously call 'Collective Responsibility'
.
It was the same argument used and being used by members of Pol Pot's gang , Robert Mugabe's gang , General Pinochet's gang , Mousy Dung's gang etc etc. Even Al Capone's gang. Just weasel words uttered by professional / amateur liars and criminals
.
All these despicable anti-democratic gangsters deserve our whole-hearted scorn and contempt.
.
T
[quote][p][bold]banknote[/bold] wrote: If you believe that HS2 is wrong but that is government policy, then you resign your cabinet position - not wait until you're sacked. This type of behavior is what gives politics a really bad name. As a lifelong Conservative, I would not vote for her.[/p][/quote]The argument used by these traitorous politicians is that they cannot speak what they think because they are governed by what they deviously call 'Collective Responsibility' . It was the same argument used and being used by members of Pol Pot's gang , Robert Mugabe's gang , General Pinochet's gang , Mousy Dung's gang etc etc. Even Al Capone's gang. Just weasel words uttered by professional / amateur liars and criminals . All these despicable anti-democratic gangsters deserve our whole-hearted scorn and contempt. . T J B Blackett
  • Score: 0

8:15pm Thu 13 Sep 12

Arnoux2827 says...

Typical politician with no moral backbone .
She should go.
Typical politician with no moral backbone . She should go. Arnoux2827
  • Score: 0

4:34pm Sat 15 Sep 12

Scarletto says...

Cheryl Gillan has let a lot of people down, been two faced and deserves to be defeated at the next election. She has displayed "tactical thinking" to suit herself and not us residents. Away with her.....
Conservatives must abandon her and deselect her as candidate before the election.
Cheryl Gillan has let a lot of people down, been two faced and deserves to be defeated at the next election. She has displayed "tactical thinking" to suit herself and not us residents. Away with her..... Conservatives must abandon her and deselect her as candidate before the election. Scarletto
  • Score: 0

11:25pm Thu 20 Sep 12

Chiltonians says...

Lets get the order right. We need in the first place to scrap Cheryl Gillan
Lets get the order right. We need in the first place to scrap Cheryl Gillan Chiltonians
  • Score: 0

11:31pm Thu 20 Sep 12

Chiltonians says...

She is simple lecturing to the already converted, very noisy, nimby minority.

I am so surprised that these London waged self interested busy bodys are so easily fooled by Mrs Gillan's new position on HS2
She is simple lecturing to the already converted, very noisy, nimby minority. I am so surprised that these London waged self interested busy bodys are so easily fooled by Mrs Gillan's new position on HS2 Chiltonians
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree