Local News RSS Feed


Text banner 2

BFP reporter's car wrongly seized

7:30am Thursday 4th September 2008

comment Comments (11)   Have your say »

By Andy Carswell »

STUNNED Bucks Free Press reporter Hannah Williams was left stranded at the roadside after her car was seized when she was wrongly accused of driving with no insurance.

A mistake by insurers Norwich Union led to Hannah being left at the side of the road by police when they took away her Ford Fiesta because she could not prove she was insured.

The national insurance database, used by police in their crackdown on uninsured drivers, had not been updated and without her certificate Hannah was unable to show she was insured.

When police called Norwich Union, the company claimed her insurance policy had lapsed.

Norwich Union has since apologised, and admitted Hannah’s details had not been passed to the database.

She said she was “made to feel like a criminal” after being fined £200 and given six penalty points, although this was later cancelled.

Hannah, 22, said: “It makes me feel very angry that such a mistake can leave you stranded on the side of the road.

“When the police said I wasn’t insured and said they would have to seize my car, my eyes almost popped out of my head.

“They asked me to sit in the back of a police car. It made me feel like a criminal.”

The police officers declined to give her a lift to the nearest town, and although left in a residential area Hannah missed the court case she was on her way to cover in Aylesbury.

She said: “When I asked how would I get back, they said ‘You have to make your own way back’.”

Hannah drove past an Automatic Number Plate Recognition camera on August 26, and a database check wrongly said she was uninsured despite Norwich Union writing to her on July 1 explaining her insurance would be automatically renewed.

After the car was seized, Hannah had a 20-minute walk from Wendover Road to Aylesbury railway station, where she had to wait 40 minutes to catch a train back to High Wycombe.

She then took a taxi home to collect her certificate, before walking to High Wycombe police station.

While there she again contacted Norwich Union and the firm admitted she was covered.

Hannah said: “I understand it’s a serious offence not to have insurance but I can’t understand someone at a call centre making a mistake resulting in the loss of my car for a day and compromising my position at work.

“I was just shocked they could get it so wrong and I wonder how many more people have had their car seized wrongly.”

Eric Nelson, spokesman for Norwich Union, said Hannah’s details had not been passed on to the national insurance database and insurance bureau.

The reason for this is being investigated, he said.

He added: “We are very sorry this happened and for any inconvenience this caused and of course we will pick up any expenses incurred.”

No comment was available from Thames Valley Police.


Your Say YourBucks

Malc London, Gerrards Cross says...
8:58am Thu 4 Sep 08

Life in Brown's Britain, everyone a criminal until you can prove otherwise. I hope some heafty compensation is forthcoming.

john_b, Wycombe says...
9:17am Thu 4 Sep 08

I imagine most uninsured drivers are driving around in the cars of relatives, and therefore are unlikely to be caught - they certainly won't be spotted by these automatic systems.

Regular Poster, High Wycombe says...
10:12am Thu 4 Sep 08

At least it proves that the recognition system works. Shame the police could not have been a little more accomodating in allowing her to have a lift to the train station -there would have been an outcry if she'd have been attacked whilst walking away.

Steve Totteridge Hill, Totteridge Hill says...
12:04pm Thu 4 Sep 08

Mistakes do happen...However I do hope you send them a big fat bill.

SDJones, Hazlemere says...
12:10pm Thu 4 Sep 08

this is so annoying when there are so many immigrants etc who drive around with no insurance and get away with it, pick on innnocent people but let the criminals do what they want!

Blueberry, S Bucks says...
12:21pm Thu 4 Sep 08

But it's the INSURERS who told the police she wasn't insured, so don't blame the police. If they don't take action about uninsured drivers/vehicles, there would be outcry too!

Certainly she ought to be due SOME compensation, but if it's too much, that just penalises other customers of the insurance company as they'd have to increase premiums.

Merge in Turn, says...
12:48pm Thu 4 Sep 08

Why didn't Hannah write this article herself? Still waiting a train to work I guess.

Blaze Falconburger, High Wycombe says...
2:11pm Thu 4 Sep 08

So I presume Norwich Union will be picking up the bill for all costs incurred due to their error and compensation for the time lost?

I doubt it, I used NU once and was unfortunate to have to claim and following that complete inefficient process I have never renewed any policy with them. That was 6 years ago, good to hear they are still on top form!

Observer of, HW says...
3:28pm Thu 4 Sep 08

If the insurance companies cannot be relied upon to provide accurate data, then the police should not be using the system until they do.

This is the second case I have heard about in a matter of a few weeks and it is the innocent insured drivers who are carrying the can.

Elmo, High Wycombe says...
1:21pm Fri 5 Sep 08

I can confirm a third Insurance company error. A typo meant my reg No. was wrong, V instead of U.

Every year I asked them to correct it and I received corrected Insurance certificate, but every time I renewed it was wrong again. So the number is wrong on the central database, so the police records would show the car as uninsured.

Hopefully this time was the last time.

rdv, marlow says...
12:24pm Sat 6 Sep 08

Earlier this year I insured my car through Post Office Insurance. I sent proof of NCB and fitting certificate for Thatcham cat2 security which was returned as acceptable. The next letter, some weeks later, informed me my policy had been cancelled as I had failed to provide proof of security. I had been driving uninsured for 2 days. I phoned to complain, they admitted it was their mistake but could not reinstate the cancelled policy. I was asked to pay the full premium again for a new policy before a refund could be issued. I changed my insurer

Your sayYourBucks

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE Bucks Free Press account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.




Forgotten your password?
Hannah Williams Hannah Williams

Sponsored Links


Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »