Blogs RSS Feed


In which Eris ponders alternative therapies

By Eris »

I have recently been dabbling in herbal medicine and alternative therapies.

Three years ago, I fell down a flight of 15 stairs at a party at university. Not my most elegant moment. In answer to the obvious questions, no, I had not been ingesting any firewater before the incident. I quaffed quite a bit afterwards though; alcohol has been used as an anaesthetic for generations (that is my excuse, and I am sticking to it like glue).

The next day, I had a train journey from Exeter to Wycombe. Not pretty. Luckily for me, the staff took pity on me, and arranged for a porter to carry my luggage across from Paddington to Marylebone, and gave me a 1st class seat, which didn’t make a difference to the fact I couldn’t sit down, but certainly helped in relation to drowning out the throbbing headache with all the free coffee I could guzzle in 2.5 hours.

I couldn’t sit down for three months, and have experienced pain and discomfort on a basis that I will refer to as somewhere between almost-constant and regular. I have had x-rays and an MRI (terrifying experience), and had various treatments. The most memorable was the physiotherapist who told me the pain was all in my head. Brill, thanks for that. About as useful as a chocolate teapot. My imagination is clearly better than I thought. There is some credence to what she says; I have noticed that when I get stressed it gets a little more pronounced. Sort of like my body says ‘aha, you are stressed, are you? Here, have something else to add to your woes! Huzzah!’

Anyhoo, I had a couple of Rheumatology appointments at the hospital, and they referred me for a course of acupuncture.

I have had two sessions so far, and honestly, I was slightly sceptical. Not to mention completely terrified. Since an episode when I was 12, I have been terrified of needles. However, this is making an amazing difference. I can sit through an entire film at the cinema without any discomfort. Believe me, this is nothing short of a miracle. And the doctor who carries out my acupuncture is fantastic. In my first session, he talked to me beforehand to make sure I was ok, and checked a number of times to make sure I was ok during. The needles have to stay in for about 15 – 20 mins, so he left to see to another patient, and I happily read my book. I didn’t feel them while they were in, and I barely even felt them when they went in. The needles go in my *ahem* lower back, so there is a fair amount of padding for them.

The NHS is starting to embrace ‘alternative’ therapies such as acupuncture and counselling. Which I actually think is fantastic. I used to see a herbalist (privately, the NHS don’t go there!), who is completely against modern medicine, she even treats her pets with herbal medicines. I don’t agree with this, I think that both modern medicine and alternative therapies have their place. When my back is painful, I am not against taking painkillers, and when a loved one has cancer I am fully in favour of an operation or chemo (as long as that is what they want!). However, I am aware that counselling can be incredibly valuable, and acupuncture seems to be helping my back pain hugely. The fact that the NHS provides it is just the icing on the cake.

We have made amazing discoveries in the last century with regards to healthcare, but treatments such as acupuncture have survived for centuries. Surely today we have room for both?


Comments(11)

Rebecca Leon says...
9:34pm Thu 4 Mar 10

An inspiring and educational story.
:
There is room for both to live side by side. Why are traditional doctors so sceptical about other methods? And why should they have the last word
:
Traditional medicines are a lot older, seems wrong to me.Time and again individuals prove that they work.
:
I'm afraid I'm growing increasingly jaded. The more I read, the more I fear the scam that is modern medicine (big bucks drug dealing really.)
:
And once you start looking into what's in a lot of stuff - aahh! - terror strikes! Mercury, lead, arsenic...
:
I'm glad your backs improved.

Eris says...
9:46pm Thu 4 Mar 10

Rebecca Leon wrote:
An inspiring and educational story. : There is room for both to live side by side. Why are traditional doctors so sceptical about other methods? And why should they have the last word : Traditional medicines are a lot older, seems wrong to me.Time and again individuals prove that they work. : I'm afraid I'm growing increasingly jaded. The more I read, the more I fear the scam that is modern medicine (big bucks drug dealing really.) : And once you start looking into what's in a lot of stuff - aahh! - terror strikes! Mercury, lead, arsenic... : I'm glad your backs improved.
Hi Rebecca
.
As you say, there is room for both. I have a great deal of time for modern medicine and for the healthcare profession. And whilst there may be some doctors who are resistent to alternative therapies, there are therapists who equally deny the positive effects of treatments such as surgery and drugs. Which in my humble opinion is ridiculous; how many thousands upon thousands more cancer or cardio patient survivors do we have now compared to even 10, 20 years ago?
.
As you say, traditional medicines are just that - traditional. And while some, like old wives' tales, are at least questionable, there are others, such as acupuncture, which can legitimately help people. But this is something the NHS seems to be recognising, which is just fantastic.
.
Mind you, having said all that, the one time I had Reiki I got an ear infection, which I treated with antibiotics. Room for all treatments, that's my opinion!

Eachban says...
10:43pm Thu 4 Mar 10

There is indeed room for both modern chemicals and traditional natural chemicals, or herbs n stuff if you prefer.
.
I use a few supplements myself, having something of an iffy back too - nothing as spectacular as taking a sober header down a stair for me though.
.
I found an osteopath to be able to work a kind of magic, and have hardly looked back.
.
There are many 'alternative' treatmenst out there. My view is if you haven't tried them, don't knock 'em - some of them are perfectly effective.

Fractal says...
11:34pm Thu 4 Mar 10

I too was sceptical when accupuncture was metioned for treatment following a torn nerve in the shoulder.

My scepticism has gone to a large degree.

The problem science has in embracing these homeopathic rememdies is the lack of consistancy with the various studies. Science likes things neatly wrapped in bite-sized chunks and will have no truck with anything less.

Times are changing an nowadays many are questioning properly what the basis of many 'old' remedies really are.

One day perhaps the two disciplines can reach harmony.

demoness says...
7:18am Fri 5 Mar 10

Rebecca Leon wrote:
An inspiring and educational story. : There is room for both to live side by side. Why are traditional doctors so sceptical about other methods? And why should they have the last word : Traditional medicines are a lot older, seems wrong to me.Time and again individuals prove that they work. : I'm afraid I'm growing increasingly jaded. The more I read, the more I fear the scam that is modern medicine (big bucks drug dealing really.) : And once you start looking into what's in a lot of stuff - aahh! - terror strikes! Mercury, lead, arsenic... : I'm glad your backs improved.
I don't think that traditional doctors are against alternative therapies - well they don't seem to be in Bucks. Afteralll wasn't Eris refered to an acupuncturist by a doctor at Amersham Hospital?

As for your assertion about the noxious substances that many modern drugs have , well you are aware of what is in some of the homeopathic treatments aren't you?

Osteopaths have been known, on a number of occassions to do more harm than good.

Anyway that is one side. Personally I believe in the body being able to heal itself to a degree and I think that some of these therapies tune into that.
I, like Eris, think there is room for both and it would appear that the NHS is beginning to think that too. :)
I,

Rebecca Leon says...
4:20pm Fri 5 Mar 10

Maybe in Bucks they're more open. A large number of close friends and family have found strong resistance when discussing alternative therapies/remedies.
:
Eczema, ear problems, MS, all have seen improvements using alternative remedies.
:
As my daughter too suffered from eczema when young, I can honestly say I've felt literally bullied by hospital (not in Bucks) staff to use steroids on her skin.
:
I've since found other ointments and dietary considerations work just as well if not better.
:
I'm not anti-traditional, just like to have a choice.

Eachban says...
3:43pm Sat 6 Mar 10

As to the superiority of manufactured drugs, I assume you are aware that these are considered to be pretty successful at clinical trial if they are effective on about 20% of cases. Not exactly setting the bar too high.
.
Modern scepticism hangs to a great degree in difficulty of doing 'double blind' testing - you can't really test for placebo reactions to acupuncture or magnets for example.

Eris says...
8:56am Sun 7 Mar 10

Many thanks for all your comments - some really interesting points have been made, I think the conflicts between 'modern' and 'traditional' treatments are perhaps unnecessary - there is a place for all of them.
.
As demoness pointed out, Bucks hospitals seem much more open to at least some alternative therapies - my acupuncture is performed by a doctor, in the hospital, and is available through the NHS. All of which point towards the fact that it is fast becoming a recognised mainstream treatment, which is just fantastic.
.
As for the 20% success rate in clinical trials, my outlook may be too simplistic, but I think if a treatment cures or helps one single person, it is a success. It is one person more than if that treatment or cure had never been made available.

Melanie1 says...
7:35pm Tue 9 Mar 10

Having been away for the weekend I've only just got around to reading this and wanted to add my two pence worth.
.
I use alternative therapies in conjunction (when needed) with conventional medicine.
.
I've had lots of acupuncture over the last few years, firstly for a dislocated knee and secondly to help with a small broken bone in my ankle and also for migraines.
.
However, I use a traditional private acupuncturist as I find him much more effective, although as the treatment is more intensive it can also, at times, be excruciatingly painful.
.
Incidentally my vet has an acupuncturist and I knew someone whose 20 year old dog has a stroke and she decided to try acupuncture to help correct her head tilt. It worked. Every 4 weeks she had acupuncture and the head tilt was corrected, into the third week the head tilt was starting to show again. This dog lived until 22 years old.
.
I've also had acupressure massage but found it too painful, so stick with the acupuncture now.

Blueberry says...
9:55pm Tue 9 Mar 10

Why assume modern medicine might be a scam without considering whether alternative therapies might be too?

demoness says...
8:50am Wed 10 Mar 10

Blueberry wrote:
Why assume modern medicine might be a scam without considering whether alternative therapies might be too?
Exactly - both have their disadvantages and advantages but they do work well together.


Latest Blog entries

May 2012 »
S M T W T F S
29 30 01 02 03 04 05
06 07 08 09 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31 01 02

RSS







About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree