USA gun laws create impossible dilemma

EARLIER this week a young man, wearing a costume of protective gear similar to that worn in a film and carrying guns entered a cinema where that film was being shown in Aurora, Colorado and shot dead 12 people, injuring around 58 more.

The death toll may well rise. The young man must, by any reasonable criteria, be deemed deranged, but he was nonetheless able to amass an arsenal of weaponry and bullets over a few weeks without alerting any responsible body to the fact or raising an inquisitorial eyebrow. In the wake of the tragedy, the cinema chain, AMC theatres, has announced: “We will not allow any guests into our theaters in costumes that make other guests feel uncomfortable and we will not permit face-covering masks or fake weapons inside our buildings.”

This announcement has triggered a stunned response from many commentators along the lines of ‘a man in fancy dress shoots 70 people in a cinema provoking the immediate banning of fancy dress in cinemas’.

It serves to highlight the impossible dilemma facing politicians of sound mind in the USA. To even suggest a tightening of the bizarre gun laws of (what has been for decades at least) the most powerful nation in the world, spells instant death to a candidate at the ballot box. The right to bear arms is so central to the beliefs of middle America.

Otherwise perfectly reasonable Americans of my acquaintance react with exactly the same level of horror and incomprehension when I suggest the removal of their inalienable right to bear arms as I feel about them having that right in the first place.

The right for an American citizen to carry arms seems a powerful, almost religious belief comparable with the rights claimed by faiths worldwide to wear certain types of clothing, to kill animals in certain ritualistic ways or revere and protect specific animals, or to pierce or mutilate their bodies. Many of the practices of belief systems alien to us perplex us and were we to delete the ‘belief systems folder’ of the human hard disk and start again, I would hope that many of them would be happily forgotten.

It would take a brave generation of republican and democratic candidates to stand up to the backlash and transitional period, were they to co-operate in taking on this apparently insoluble problem. I am sure that many would love to but simply daren’t.

Comments (2)

12:35pm Mon 30 Jul 12

Metalkatt says...

Speaking as a USistani, I don't really see the need for guns. However, on the whole, this is and always has been a reactionary nation--we don't think so much about what should be or what's best, but we freak out at the thought of someone trying to take something away from us. A bit like toddlers that way.

The theatre owners can't rally do anything else. If they're in a concealed-carry state, they can't go around demanding that everyone check their guns at the door. When it comes to costume props, they should be checked to make sure they are just that--props. But other than that, our hands are just tied.

We dare not do anything because we're trapped by a populace that has spurned education in favour of "reality television." Those in power take advantage of this fact, and manipulate that populace to their own ends with the slick remorselessness of sociopaths.

We live in a fascist nation now (go look up the definition and hallmarks of fascism before you go jumping all over me), and we're kinda stuck.
Speaking as a USistani, I don't really see the need for guns. However, on the whole, this is and always has been a reactionary nation--we don't think so much about what should be or what's best, but we freak out at the thought of someone trying to take something away from us. A bit like toddlers that way. The theatre owners can't rally do anything else. If they're in a concealed-carry state, they can't go around demanding that everyone check their guns at the door. When it comes to costume props, they should be checked to make sure they are just that--props. But other than that, our hands are just tied. We dare not do anything because we're trapped by a populace that has spurned education in favour of "reality television." Those in power take advantage of this fact, and manipulate that populace to their own ends with the slick remorselessness of sociopaths. We live in a fascist nation now (go look up the definition and hallmarks of fascism before you go jumping all over me), and we're kinda stuck. Metalkatt

2:50pm Fri 3 Aug 12

Waspilot says...

Let's hope that those poor victims also are gainfully employed with health care coverage. If not, they risk losing their lives, and their families risk losing their life savings trying to get medical care for their loved ones.

The political lines are not drawn between Republican and Democrat, they are drawn between the filthy rich and the rest of us.
Let's hope that those poor victims also are gainfully employed with health care coverage. If not, they risk losing their lives, and their families risk losing their life savings trying to get medical care for their loved ones. The political lines are not drawn between Republican and Democrat, they are drawn between the filthy rich and the rest of us. Waspilot

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree