Send your news, photos and videos by texting bucksfreepress to 80360 or email
6:53pm Tuesday 3rd November 2009
A few days ago a news article was published on this site about the selection of a candidate to stand at the next general election in the hope of becoming the MP for Wycombe.
According to the report it took five rounds of voting before one of the six candidates was finally chosen. The winning candidate had lived in our area some years ago but apart from that they had no other connections with our town.
This blog is not intended to be about to the specifics of the selection process that took place recently neither is it intended to discuss the merits of or pass comment in any way on the person chosen however the whole process intrigued me.
Ever since reading the news article I have been asking myself “What does it take to become an MP?”
Is there not a great honour in being the MP for a town? I think there is.
Not only is there honour but the salary of £64,766 plus allowances (don't mention the allowances!) and 80 days summer holiday are most attractive. Most of us can only dream of such a highly paid job.
What amazes me most is that despite having a population of over 100,000 people recent history suggest the chances of a local person becoming our MP is practically nil.
In such a densely populated area there must be someone with the talents to represent our town in parliament.
I wonder how many more of the MPs who go to make up the entire parliament don't actually have very strong connections with the town they represent?
Does a parliament made up of too many MPs from outside the area which they represent not make a mockery of the whole idea of a local representative? Why not ditch the first past the post system and introduce proportional representation instead?
Anyone can stand as an independent but unless you have the backing of one of the big parties you have very little hope of being elected.
It's almost that rather than voting for a person we are being asked to vote for a party and the candidate is just a name on the ballot paper.
It helps if you are a prominent local business man or local celebrity as your popularity would help carry you through but mere mortals like myself have no hope.
I for one would like to see rules brought in to ensure that our elected representative was more of a local person.
Sadly the position of MP has become diluted similar to that of the players in a top-flight football team. Rather the using local talent players (or MPs) are simply brought in and the supporters (or electors) have no say in the matter.
What do you think?
Comments(71)
Edna_Welthorpe
says...
8:22pm Tue 3 Nov 09
demoness
says...
9:41pm Tue 3 Nov 09
ivor
says...
1:51am Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor
says...
1:51am Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor
says...
1:52am Wed 4 Nov 09
Lorrainej
says...
7:49am Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor wrote:Yes, I'm sure you are right regarding the apathy, everybody wants to shout about it, but most do nothing.
Re the comments of Lorrainej at 7:05pm ~ It will be interesting to see how many comments this blog attracts. I suspect there is a general feeling of apathy when it comes to anything to do with parliament. ~ I am sure I could easily do the job of a MP but I fear that I may not be able to tow the party line and would probably speak out when I see injustice. ~ Thank you for your valued comment.
Lorrainej
says...
7:50am Wed 4 Nov 09
demoness wrote:Hope you feel better today.
I found that interesting Ivor but am nursing this wretched cold virus thing that is going around so can't share my thoughts tonight. I will do tomorrow.
demoness
says...
8:38am Wed 4 Nov 09
demoness
says...
8:43am Wed 4 Nov 09
Lorrainej wrote:Thank you. I feel slightly better but do tend to take illness as a personal affront to me :)
demoness wrote: I found that interesting Ivor but am nursing this wretched cold virus thing that is going around so can't share my thoughts tonight. I will do tomorrow.Hope you feel better today.
Lorrainej
says...
9:21am Wed 4 Nov 09
demoness wrote:Yes, I know what you mean
Lorrainej wrote:Thank you. I feel slightly better but do tend to take illness as a personal affront to me :)demoness wrote: I found that interesting Ivor but am nursing this wretched cold virus thing that is going around so can't share my thoughts tonight. I will do tomorrow.Hope you feel better today.
Lorrainej
says...
9:34am Wed 4 Nov 09
demoness
says...
10:35am Wed 4 Nov 09
SteveBaker
says...
10:55am Wed 4 Nov 09
demoness
says...
10:58am Wed 4 Nov 09
Lorrainej
says...
11:14am Wed 4 Nov 09
SteveBaker wrote:www.stevebaker.info
I understand people's disillusionment with politics. It is a desire to improve things which motivates me. On the facts of the process, please see this document: http://www.conservat ives.com/pdf/howtomp .pdf Ivor writes: "The winning candidate had lived in our area some years ago but apart from that they had no other connections with our town." However, I have had an unbroken relationship with the area since August 2007: - From August 2007 to March 2009, I lived in Walter's Ash. That is just outside the Wycombe constituency of course. - I have attended church in a nearby village since autumn 2007. I did not change churches when we moved. - I volunteered in Wycombe Winter Night Shelter last winter. My wife and I moved to RAF Brize Norton in March. This has made me personally known to David Cameron, a fact which should help the people of Wycombe in due course. We are looking forward to moving into the Constituency as soon as possible. A comment by nick591 of Prestwood on the following article is relevant: http://www.bucksfree press.co.uk/news/pol itics/4713817.Former _RAF_man_is_Wycombe_ s_Tory_MP_candidate/ He writes: "Too many people moan about their local MP without ever speaking to them or attempting to find out anything about them at all." I start knocking on doors on Saturday. I hope I find people in and I look forward to getting to know you. We can only defeat this despairing cynicism together. Steve Baker Conservative PPC for Wycombe
Blueberry
says...
1:38pm Wed 4 Nov 09
brachyura
says...
4:18pm Wed 4 Nov 09
SteveBaker
says...
4:50pm Wed 4 Nov 09
tom.marlow
says...
4:53pm Wed 4 Nov 09
J B Blackett
says...
5:55pm Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor
says...
6:29pm Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor
says...
6:30pm Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor
says...
6:30pm Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor
says...
6:31pm Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor
says...
6:32pm Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor
says...
6:33pm Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor
says...
6:33pm Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor
says...
6:33pm Wed 4 Nov 09
Lorrainej
says...
6:42pm Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor wrote:Well said Ivor
Re the comments of Lorrainej at 7:49am ~ Well I am prepared to speak out and speak my mind. Perhaps if there were more people like me perhaps things would change? Maybe they need people like me in parliament? ~ You can rest assured that I would not tow the party line. If something is wrong then I speak up to try to get things done. ~ Thank you for your valued comment.
ivor
says...
7:40pm Wed 4 Nov 09
faisal mahmood
says...
8:02pm Wed 4 Nov 09
Morag
says...
8:23pm Wed 4 Nov 09
tom.marlow
says...
8:58pm Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor wrote:The role of MPs is to run the country and their concern should be issues that affect the country as a whole. They are obligated to represent the views of their constituents on national issues.
Re the comments of tom.marlow at 4:53pm ~ Surely living amongst the constituents is vital to being a successful MP otherwise how will you know what the issues that need addressing are? ~ Having MP's that tow the part line is alright if the Government is in touch with reality.... ~ Do you think PR would be good for Council elections then? It would be interesting to know what WDC would look like if PR was applied.... ~ Thank you for your valued comment.
brachyura
says...
9:12pm Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor wrote:As Tom says, an MP is there to run the country, so I'm sure a new person would certainly have the necessary experience of life.
Re the comments of brachyura at 4:18pm ~ But does a new person have the necessary level of experience of life in the town? ~ Indeed I have lived in Wycombe all my life and worked in Wycombe for many years. This experience gives me a deep insight into the town and it's people surely that is exactly what is required for a MP? ~ Indeed it is nice to see Steve commenting on this blog. Maybe he will become a regular reader and come to see the issues facing the towns people that I highlight here. ~ Thank you for your valued comment.
Lorrainej
says...
9:21pm Wed 4 Nov 09
tom.marlow wrote:As soon as I had sent it I realised, I will check on wikipedia, they have some interesting facts, many thanks.
ivor wrote: Re the comments of tom.marlow at 4:53pm ~ Surely living amongst the constituents is vital to being a successful MP otherwise how will you know what the issues that need addressing are? ~ Having MP's that tow the part line is alright if the Government is in touch with reality.... ~ Do you think PR would be good for Council elections then? It would be interesting to know what WDC would look like if PR was applied.... ~ Thank you for your valued comment.The role of MPs is to run the country and their concern should be issues that affect the country as a whole. They are obligated to represent the views of their constituents on national issues. . As far as local issues that can be addressed by national government are concerned, as I said before its easy enough to communicate with your MP wherever they live. I emailed Mr Goodman a number fo times - not that I got any sort of sensible response. . I'm in favour of PR at both national and local levels. But it does naturally lead to much larger constituencies. . Incidentally, apologies for pedantry, both Ivor and Lorraine, but the expression is "to toe the line", not "to tow the line". Theres an interesting wikipedia article on how it arose.
demoness
says...
9:30pm Wed 4 Nov 09
tom.marlow
says...
11:56pm Wed 4 Nov 09
ivor
says...
12:06am Thu 5 Nov 09
ivor
says...
12:06am Thu 5 Nov 09
ivor
says...
12:07am Thu 5 Nov 09
ivor
says...
12:07am Thu 5 Nov 09
ivor
says...
12:07am Thu 5 Nov 09
ivor
says...
12:07am Thu 5 Nov 09
ivor
says...
12:08am Thu 5 Nov 09
Lorrainej
says...
5:34am Thu 5 Nov 09
demoness wrote:No I realise that, but it is a bit like this blog, it is an opinion. But if anybody disagrees or has any better suggestions, they can add to the content. They are volunteers that add the content, so if it is inaccurate, please add to it. Without the input of the volunteers it would not exist.
wikipedia isn't always the most accurate place in the world though...
brachyura
says...
6:25am Thu 5 Nov 09
Lorrainej
says...
6:32am Thu 5 Nov 09
brachyura wrote:But most importantly, people listen to Ivor and they respond, look at his readership and reponses. He gets more that the other stories on local MP's etc, he must be doing something right. Back Ivor.
Doesn't matter as Ivor the MP is never going to happen. . You state "I have all the necessary characteristics i.e. communication, intellect, ability to relate to people, campaigning skills, leadership, drive and conviction." . Personally I think your blogs have shown that you are lacking in a few of these skills. . Then again you constantly moan about your income, and are full of hot air so perhaps being an MP is for you.
demoness
says...
6:43am Thu 5 Nov 09
Lorrainej
says...
6:47am Thu 5 Nov 09
brachyura
says...
6:48am Thu 5 Nov 09
Lorrainej wrote:The number of comments does not mean much (half of the comments made on the blog are made by Ivor himself), and just recently the majority of the remaining half are made by you complaining about other posters.
brachyura wrote: Doesn't matter as Ivor the MP is never going to happen. . You state "I have all the necessary characteristics i.e. communication, intellect, ability to relate to people, campaigning skills, leadership, drive and conviction." . Personally I think your blogs have shown that you are lacking in a few of these skills. . Then again you constantly moan about your income, and are full of hot air so perhaps being an MP is for you.But most importantly, people listen to Ivor and they respond, look at his readership and reponses. He gets more that the other stories on local MP's etc, he must be doing something right. Back Ivor.
Lorrainej
says...
6:52am Thu 5 Nov 09
brachyura wrote:See my response 6.47
Lorrainej wrote:The number of comments does not mean much (half of the comments made on the blog are made by Ivor himself), and just recently the majority of the remaining half are made by you complaining about other posters. . People respond to Ivor but rarely do they respond positively to his ideas and he fails to listen to their point if view. . Back him if you wish but I certainly wouldn't back someone who.... . does not believe in global warming. . thinks that queuing in the post office is equivalent to the probles of the third world. . etc etc . Besides he clearly is not a man of action as despite your flirting with him he has failed to make a move...nudge, nudge wink, winkbrachyura wrote: Doesn't matter as Ivor the MP is never going to happen. . You state "I have all the necessary characteristics i.e. communication, intellect, ability to relate to people, campaigning skills, leadership, drive and conviction." . Personally I think your blogs have shown that you are lacking in a few of these skills. . Then again you constantly moan about your income, and are full of hot air so perhaps being an MP is for you.But most importantly, people listen to Ivor and they respond, look at his readership and reponses. He gets more that the other stories on local MP's etc, he must be doing something right. Back Ivor.
demoness
says...
6:59am Thu 5 Nov 09
Lorrainej
says...
7:02am Thu 5 Nov 09
brachyura
says...
7:03am Thu 5 Nov 09
Lorrainej
says...
7:08am Thu 5 Nov 09
brachyura wrote:I thought I was, or are you talking about a different day
Lorraine you are as deluded as Ivor. . You complain about other people that comment but perhaps you should lead by example and post comments that are directly related to the subject.
demoness
says...
7:13am Thu 5 Nov 09
Lorrainej wrote:LOL
No, I have Ivor
Lorrainej
says...
7:19am Thu 5 Nov 09
tom.marlow
says...
9:08am Thu 5 Nov 09
ivor wrote:Try emailing your MP....
Re the comments of tom.marlow at 8:58pm ~ But surely the local issues also have to be taken in to account? ~ Do the MP's reply to e-mails? Surely they must be very busy if they do. ~ Thank you for your valued comment.
tom.marlow
says...
9:20am Thu 5 Nov 09
ivor wrote:In my experience the content on wikipedia is generally reliable. I have not found fault in any of the articles on things I know a lot about.
Re the comments of Lorrainej at 9:21pm ~ Wikipedia may have many interesting facts on it but the question is are they correct? ~ Thank you for your valued comment.
tom.marlow
says...
9:25am Thu 5 Nov 09
Lorrainej
says...
9:27am Thu 5 Nov 09
Lorrainej
says...
9:30am Thu 5 Nov 09
tom.marlow wrote:How do you spell check here, I don't know how to do that
ooops print, not pront. need to get my spell checker serviced :-)
tom.marlow
says...
9:45am Thu 5 Nov 09
Lorrainej
says...
9:49am Thu 5 Nov 09
ivor
says...
12:58am Fri 6 Nov 09
ivor
says...
12:58am Fri 6 Nov 09
ivor
says...
12:58am Fri 6 Nov 09
ivor
says...
12:59am Fri 6 Nov 09
Lorrainej
says...
8:23am Fri 6 Nov 09
ivor wrote:Glad to hear it Ivor, too much sleeze around these days. Could be an interesting blog I suppose.
Re the comments of Lorrainej at 6:52am ~ Indeed I am an honourable person. There is no hanky-panky when I am around. ~ Thank you for your valued comment.
ivor
says...
3:02pm Sun 8 Nov 09
Find a job in Buckinghamshire.
Search Now »
Make a date in Buckinghamshire now!
Search Now »
Search for properties across the UK.
Search Now »
Find used vehicles for sale in Buckinghamshire
Search Now »
Lorrainej says...
7:05pm Tue 3 Nov 09